Chainsaw stihl or husqvarna which is better

Pros and cons of Calm

Stihl’s chainsaws are considered one of the most reliable and, for this reason, are very popular among professional lumberjacks who are used to working with powerful and reliable chainsaws. But if you look at the statistics of sales of household chainsaws Calm, then we can conclude that they are particularly popular. For example, the Shtil MS 180 chainsaw, since its appearance on sale, annually occupies top positions in the ratings of such Internet portals as the Yandex market.

The pluses of Calm 180 include:

• Light weight, which is 3.9 kg;
• Power sufficient to perform work on a personal plot and not only;
• Maintainability and availability of the Shtil company, a large number of well-organized services;
• The quality of the materials from which the chainsaw bodies are made.

All these advantages can be attributed to any product of the German company, but there is also one main disadvantage.

Compared to competitors, Stihl chainsaws have a rather high cost of both the tools themselves and the spare parts intended for their repair.

In turn, the high price of spare parts stimulates the emergence of a large number of low-quality spare parts intended to replace original and manufactured mainly in China. The installation of such spare parts is carried out in service centers that are not authorized to repair Stihl chainsaws, which entails a decrease in the service life of the tools and adversely affects the manufacturer’s image.

Recently, the Shtil company began to produce the most popular chainsaw model. Shtil MS 180 at a plant located in China. As representatives of the company explain, this is due to large volumes of products and preferential conditions for production. Also, representatives note that the transfer of production did not affect the quality of the products, for the reason that the control of all stages of production remained at the same level.

Comparison of the most popular models of Stihl and Husqvarna chainsaws

If we compare the popular Stihl and Husqvarna tools in terms of power, then the main competitor of the Calm 180 at Husqvarna is the Husqvarna 135 model.

The power of both is 1.5 kW. At the moment, Husqvarna loses not only in cost, since its price is slightly higher, but also in the volume of the cylinder, which is 40.9 cm³, while that of Calm, the volume is 31.8 cm³. If we consider this difference from the technical point of view, we can conclude that the Husqvarna engine with such a volume should consume more fuel, since the consumption of the fuel mixture is directly related to the cylinder volume.

The second moment in which Husqvarna loses to Calm 180 is weight. Calm weighs 3.9 kg, and Husqvarna is half a kilogram more. Not much difference, but still.

The advantage of Husqvarna 135 over Shtil 180 is a quick-detachable filter that can be washed and used after multiple cleaning. Calm does not have this, but it is possible to choose an additional set of tools, for example, to purchase Calm 180C or 180C-BE, which have an easy start, as well as the ability to adjust the chain tension, without the help of additional tools.

Thus, when choosing between 180 Stihl or Husqvarna 135, it is wiser and more profitable to purchase Calm 180, since it has long been the most popular chainsaw in the Russian Federation, unlike Husqvarna.

For those who live in rural areas and do not have the opportunity to repair tools in service centers, the purchase of Calm 180 is more expedient for the reason that this chainsaw can be repaired independently.

Now let’s compare the 180 with the budget version of Husqvarna, model 236.

Its power is 1.4 kW, which is already lower than that of the Shtil 180 chainsaw, and the working volume is higher and amounts to 38.2 cm³. The price is slightly lower than that of the Calm 180, but is it worth saving, while losing power and, accordingly, performance.

Another Husqvarna model with which the 180 can be compared is the Husqvarna 240.

Their price and engine power are the same, but Husqvarna loses in terms of weight and cylinder volume. Its weight is 4.7 kg, which is almost a whole kilogram more than that of Calm 180, and its volume is 38.2 cm³.

Below you can watch a video in which a specialist in the sales and repair of chainsaws expresses his opinion about the household models Shtil and Huskvarna.

Pros and cons of Husqvarna

One of the advantages of Husqvarna chainsaws is their cost, as a rule, it is slightly lower than that of Calm tools, although the difference is insignificant in some cases. You can also note the build quality of tools and materials from which they are made.

Husqvarna chainsaws are produced in many countries, including at a plant in the Moscow region city of Khimki.

Buying first chainsaw, Husqvarna or Stihl ?

The most popular model, for example, the Husqvarna 135, has a slightly lower cost than the competitor Shtil MC 180. We will compare these models in more detail a little later, but for now I would like to note that the European environmental standard is clearly traced in the technical solutions of Husqvarna. This means that the company primarily cares about the quality of the exhaust of the tool, which in some cases makes it sacrifice the maximum power of chainsaws. A striking example of such a company policy is the X-Torq® system. For the Russian Federation, this system is useless, since in our country there are no strict standards for the quality of exhaust.

It is worth noting that until 2015, Husqvarna’s 236 and 240 models had a number of factory defects, to eliminate which the company had to modernize these chainsaws. precisely, the chainsaws had defective carburetors and piston rings. After 2015, this fact was officially recognized by the company, and they also provided a complete list of defects in the 236 and 240 models.

Husqvarna or stihl which is better than a chainsaw

Before buying a chainsaw, the question certainly arises: which chainsaw is better than Calm or Husqvarna?

It is impossible to answer unequivocally, since everyone chooses the instrument that he likes. It is for this reason that in this article we will consider the main pros and cons of the Calm and Husqvarna tools, knowing which it is much easier to make a choice when buying.

It can be noted that the Shtil and Husqvarna tools are perfectly designed and well adapted to the climatic conditions of the Russian Federation and, with proper use and maintenance, can serve for a long time. It is quite difficult to compare the tools of these companies, since their quality is very high.

Husqvarna or Calm. which of these chainsaws is better?

An intriguing question, isn’t it? I am sure that many connoisseurs of these brands of instrument have been asked, are asked and will be asked. Of course, there are other worthy manufacturers of chainsaws, but it was Husqvarna and Shtil who were made to adapt to our Russian conditions, it was these companies that earned the trust and respect in the hands of a stern Russian peasant for many years! And if so. so be it, consider these brands and this difficult question. Husqvarna or Calm?

In fact, such a burning question, in my opinion, is tantamount to an unresolved problem that has eternally tormented all scientific minds. who was born, a chicken or an egg? Indeed, this theorem has ardent supporters of the chicken, and there are ardent opponents. supporters of the egg. So in our case. adherents of Husqvarna and admirers of Calm. Let’s look at this difficult question.

To begin with, it is necessary to specifically pose the question. what exactly in these saws of different companies interests this or that supporter: appearance, power, convenience, reliability, service life, price. What is the purpose of using the saw. professional or for everyday needs in everyday life.

What chainsaw to buy? Stihl MS 311 vs Husqvarna 460 Rancher: Honest Overview and Comparison

Let’s take a look at the professional saws of Huska and Stihl and evaluate their appearance.

By the way about the “caps”! If we consider the protection “winter-summer” in which the penetration of moisture, snow into the saw carburetor (and cooling in the summer) is protected, then, in my opinion, the Huska design is much better. I know that many will begin to argue and argue that “adapting” Calm, including a separate top cover with a marking jumper and a “side” for the starter, is more convenient and reliable, but in practice it is not a fig it is not more effective than the Huskvarnovskaya defense.

We know very well that when the saw “grabs” the snow during the felling in winter, it starts “coughing, spitting” and stalling. I have worked with both presented models for a considerable time and I can confidently declare that Calm in this respect is much more capricious than his opponent! And the Husqvarnoy filter is made of better quality than the Calm filter.

To disassemble the saw in the forest at the workplace and quickly fix the malfunction, you need an asterisk wrench. For Husqvarna, one main key is quite enough, which in itself is more convenient to use than Shtil’s “balloon”.

• 137E and 142E. Husqvarna plant in the USA;
• 257, 254XP, 262XP, 262XPH. Husqvarna factories in Russia, in the well-known city of Khimki
• 268, 61, 55, 272XP, 281XP, 288XP. Husqvarna plant in Brazil.

The rest of the chainsaw models are produced directly in the homeland of Husqvarna, that is, in Sweden. If you come across another country of the manufacturer not mentioned above, then before you is a fake!

As for Calm, judging by the information from VIKI, it is the best-selling brand of chainsaws on the planet.

The geography of the plants of the legendary company is as follows: Germany, USA, Switzerland, Austria, Brazil and China. In the homeland of the saw. Germany, there are 3 powerful factories that specialize in specific saw units and units. In one, crankshafts, polymer parts, tires are made, in the other. electric saws, in the third. parts from magnesium alloy. The plant in the USA manufactures crankshafts, tires, spare parts, processes piston and assembles units. The most popular brand of Calm MS 180, which is acquired by the majority of the population in Russia, is produced and assembled at a factory in the USA. In Brazil, in addition to the classic list of product manufacturing, pistons and cylinders are also produced. Saw chains are being manufactured in Switzerland, blowers in Austria. And, of course, how can we do without China, which produces, probably, everything for the Stihl saw.

So what are we looking at. which models? Let’s evaluate the saws from the professional line, those that, in my opinion, are the most popular and used in our logging. I mean Stihl 361 and Husqvarna 365 SP.

The cost of these saws is almost the same: Husqvarna 365 SP. 22 990 rubles, STIHL MS 361 16. 22 490 rubles. Naturally, one should take into account the difference in cost depending on the regions, somewhere it is significantly less, and somewhere more. There are some differences in technical parameters:

Husqvarna 365 SP:

Calm MS 361 16:

As we can see, Husqvarna has a larger working volume compared to Calm with the same power. Most likely, the same power is achieved by increasing the speed of the Calm engine, and from this we can conclude that the load in the engine is increasing. Accordingly, the Calm engine is subject to greater wear and a reduction in the operation of the piston engine. Though…

However, there is unconfirmed information that the Huska 365 is not assembled in Sweden, but in Turkey, and the quality of the piston and cylinder is in great doubt. On the contrary, Calm is distinguished by the quality of assembly, the individual units of which are assembled at certain factories under the control of the company. So these are all not good arguments for the quality of the two firms.

Another no less discussed and controversial issue in the “Calm and Khuska case” is a cutting set: a bar and chains. A global dispute

So, what is the significant difference between Husqvarna and Shtil’s sawing bars? That’s right. the presence of inlets for lubrication of the driven sprocket: Calm does not have them, Husqvarna has them. I want to make a reservation right away that these remarks refer to the standard equipment of the saws sold, by your decision, the tires can be replaced additionally. So this is a disadvantage or an advantage?

It seemed to the calmness to be superfluous in the design of the tire, since the lubrication of the driven sprocket on the tire is performed in full. In addition, to increase the service life, it is planned to fill the gearbox with specialized oil, which will ensure proper penetration and lubrication of the saw elements. But is this significant for us. Russians, who pour not only autol, but also working off into the gearbox of the tool. There is not only an asterisk, but also the oil pump cannot withstand!

Huskvarnovtsy decided to play it safe and endowed their offspring with additional channels for lubricating the sprocket, which is injected with grease from a specialized syringe. Thus, the sprocket is lubricated with oil from the gearbox in the lower channels of the bar (intended for lubricating the chain) and grease from a syringe from the upper holes of the bar. Ideal. yes, but as always there is BUT!

With large-scale logging, when it is necessary to keep a high pace of work, it is not always possible to inject an asterisk, in particular in winter, when the grease freezes in the syringe, and Russian laziness plays an important role.

Another important clarification. The fact is that Calm is the only company in the world that independently produces a cutting attachment, in our case a saw bar. Husqvarna, as far as I know, uses not only his products in this area, which wants the best, but also uses the developments of other companies. For example, I have a negative attitude towards Husqvarna tires and have always tried to use tires from other manufacturers, in particular, tires from the Oregon company, which justified itself on the Husqvarna chainsaw. Of course, the choice among professional tires is not uncommon and there are durable Husqvarna tires. from more than 3000 rubles, but the prices, as we can see, are already “biting”. I used a good Husqvarnov tire with oblique channels for chain lubrication and a removable sprocket. But again the price.

As for the shock absorbers of the models I presented, I can confidently call Stihl the leader. For a year of working with him, I never broke a single shock absorber, although the saw wobbled. be healthy!

The topic of oil for two-stroke engines should be touched upon. Of course, I should write a separate article about this, but I will touch on some points.

This applies to the organoleptic properties of oils from both companies. Have you noticed how “drags” from Husqvarne oil? As if the cats pissed. the stench is unbearable. Yes, to hell with him with this stench, we are not going to smell it, the point is in the distinctive feature of the smell that gives off ammonia. If the presence of ammonia substances is really present in the product, then this is “not a buzz” for the instrument, or rather for its engine! On the contrary, calm oil has a specifically pleasant odor, thereby causing greater confidence in its product.

Well, my readers, on this I will probably round off. Of course, I did not touch on everything, but this requires you, who will supplement or, on the contrary, subtract my observations and arguments. In the meantime, it’s up to you to decide which is better for Husqvarna or Calm.

I generally consider the Makita DCS4610-40 and Stihl MS 180 40cm models. Guys, somebody fumbles?
Sorry, that is not a question)))

What to choose

When choosing a chainsaw, it is more advisable to give preference to the models of the Shtil company, even though they are a little more expensive. Calm owners have a little more advantages. They can make a choice: repair the instrument themselves or contact a certified service center. There are more spare parts for Calm, and if necessary, you can purchase less expensive analogs of the original parts. Calm, this is a good time-tested tool.

Below you can watch a video in which a specialist in the sales and repair of chainsaws expresses his opinion about the household models Shtil and Huskvarna.

Which chainsaw is better?

Having compared the popular chainsaws Shtil and Huskarna, we had the opportunity to answer the question: Calm or Huskvarna which is better? But we will not answer it, since everyone has to make a decision for himself, we just provided the actual information, slightly diluting it with comments, for those who are poorly versed in technical nuances.

Which chainsaws are better than husqvarna or calm

Husqvarna or Calm

Husqvarna or Calm. which of these chainsaws is better?

An intriguing question, isn’t it? I am sure that many connoisseurs of these brands of instrument have been asked, are asked and will be asked. Of course, there are other worthy manufacturers of chainsaws, but it was Husqvarna and Shtil who were made to adapt to our Russian conditions, it was these companies that earned the trust and respect in the hands of a stern Russian peasant for many years! And if so. so be it, consider these brands and this difficult question. Husqvarna or Calm?

In fact, such a burning question, in my opinion, is tantamount to an unresolved problem that has eternally tormented all scientific minds. who was born, a chicken or an egg? Indeed, this theorem has ardent supporters of the chicken, and there are ardent opponents. supporters of the egg. So in our case. adherents of Husqvarna and admirers of Calm. Let’s look at this difficult question.

To begin with, it is necessary to specifically pose the question. what exactly in these saws of different companies interests this or that supporter: appearance, power, convenience, reliability, service life, price. What is the purpose of using the saw. professional or for everyday needs in everyday life.

Let’s take a look at the professional saws of Huska and Stihl and evaluate their appearance.

By the way about the “caps”! If we consider the protection “winter-summer” in which the penetration of moisture, snow into the saw carburetor (and cooling in the summer) is protected, then, in my opinion, the Huska design is much better. I know that many will begin to argue and argue that “adapting” Calm, including a separate top cover with a marking jumper and a “side” for the starter, is more convenient and reliable, but in practice it is not a fig it is not more effective than the Huskvarnovskaya defense.

We know very well that when the saw “grabs” the snow during the felling in winter, it starts “coughing, spitting” and stalling. I have worked with both presented models for a considerable time and I can confidently declare that Calm in this respect is much more capricious than his opponent! And the Husqvarnoy filter is made of better quality than the Calm filter.

To disassemble the saw in the forest at the workplace and quickly fix the malfunction, you need an asterisk wrench. For Husqvarna, one main key is quite enough, which in itself is more convenient to use than Shtil’s “balloon”.

Both firms have a wide range of professional and household models (of course, farm models). However, some modifications of the company are made directly in different countries. For example, the Husqvarna company represents chainsaws of specific models by other manufacturers in the following states:

• 137E and 142E. Husqvarna plant in the USA;
• 257, 254XP, 262XP, 262XPH. Husqvarna factories in Russia, in the well-known city of Khimki
• 268, 61, 55, 272XP, 281XP, 288XP. Husqvarna plant in Brazil.

The rest of the chainsaw models are produced directly in the homeland of Husqvarna, that is, in Sweden. If you come across another country of the manufacturer not mentioned above, then before you is a fake!

As for Calm, judging by the information from VIKI, it is the best-selling brand of chainsaws on the planet.

The geography of the plants of the legendary company is as follows: Germany, USA, Switzerland, Austria, Brazil and China. In the homeland of the saw. Germany, there are 3 powerful factories that specialize in specific saw units and units. In one, crankshafts, polymer parts, tires are made, in the other. electric saws, in the third. parts from magnesium alloy. The plant in the USA manufactures crankshafts, tires, spare parts, processes piston and assembles units. The most popular brand of Calm MS 180, which is acquired by the majority of the population in Russia, is produced and assembled at a factory in the USA. In Brazil, in addition to the classic list of product manufacturing, pistons and cylinders are also produced. Saw chains are being manufactured in Switzerland, blowers in Austria. And, of course, how can we do without China, which produces, probably, everything for the Stihl saw.

So what are we looking at. which models? Let’s evaluate the saws from the professional line, those that, in my opinion, are the most popular and used in our logging industry. I mean Stihl 361 and Husqvarna 365 SP.

The cost of these saws is almost the same: Husqvarna 365 SP. 22,990 rubles, STIHL MS 361 16. 22,490 rubles. Naturally, one should take into account the difference in cost depending on the regions, somewhere it is significantly less, and somewhere more. There are some differences in technical parameters:

Husqvarna 365 SP:

Calm MS 361 16:

As we can see, Husqvarna has a larger working volume compared to Calm with the same power. Most likely, the same power is achieved by increasing the speed of the Calm engine, and from this we can conclude that the load in the engine is increasing. Accordingly, the Calm engine is subject to greater wear and a reduction in the operation of the piston engine. Though…

However, there is unconfirmed information that the Huska 365 is not assembled in Sweden, but in Turkey, and the quality of the piston and cylinder is in great doubt. On the contrary, Calm is distinguished by the quality of assembly, the individual units of which are assembled at certain factories under the control of the company. So these are all not good arguments for the quality of the two firms.

Another no less discussed and controversial issue in the “Calm and Khuska case” is a cutting set: a bar and chains. A global dispute

So, what is the significant difference between Husqvarna and Shtil’s sawing bars? That’s right. the presence of inlets for lubrication of the driven sprocket: Calm does not have them, Husqvarna has them. I want to make a reservation right away that these remarks refer to the standard equipment of the saws sold, by your decision, the tires can be replaced additionally. So this is a disadvantage or an advantage?

It seemed to the calmness to be superfluous in the design of the tire, since the lubrication of the driven sprocket on the tire is performed in full. In addition, to increase the service life, it is planned to fill the gearbox with specialized oil, which will ensure proper penetration and lubrication of the saw elements. But is this significant for us. Russians, who pour not only autol, but also working off into the gearbox of the tool. There is not only an asterisk, but also the oil pump cannot withstand!

Huskvarnovtsy decided to play it safe and endowed their offspring with additional channels for lubricating the sprocket, which is injected with grease from a specialized syringe. Thus, the sprocket is lubricated with oil from the gearbox in the lower channels of the bar (intended for lubricating the chain) and grease from a syringe from the upper holes of the bar. Ideal. yes, but as always there is BUT!

With large-scale logging, when it is necessary to keep a high pace of work, it is not always possible to inject an asterisk, in particular in winter, when the grease freezes in the syringe, and Russian laziness plays an important role.

Another important clarification. The fact is that Calm is the only company in the world that independently produces a cutting attachment, in our case a saw bar. Husqvarna, as far as I know, uses not only his products in this area, which wants the best, but also uses the developments of other companies. For example, I have a negative attitude towards Husqvarna tires and have always tried to use tires from other manufacturers, in particular, tires from the Oregon company, which justified itself on the Husqvarna chainsaw. Of course, the choice among professional tires is not uncommon and there are durable Husqvarna tires. from more than 3000 rubles, but the prices, as we can see, are already “biting”. I used a good Husqvarnov tire with oblique channels for chain lubrication and a removable sprocket. But again the price.

As for the shock absorbers of the models I presented, I can confidently call Stihl the leader. For a year of working with him, I never broke a single shock absorber, although the saw wobbled. be healthy!

The topic of oil for two-stroke engines should be touched upon. Of course, I should write a separate article about this, but I will touch on some points.

This applies to the organoleptic properties of oils from both companies. Have you noticed how “drags” from Husqvarne oil? As if the cats pissed. the stench is unbearable. Yes, to hell with him with this stench, we are not going to smell it, the point is in the distinctive feature of the smell that gives off ammonia. If the presence of ammonia substances is really present in the product, then this is “not a buzz” for the instrument, or rather for its engine! On the contrary, calm oil has a specifically pleasant odor, thereby causing greater confidence in its product.

Well, my readers, on this I will probably round off. Of course, I did not touch on everything, but this requires you, who will supplement or, on the contrary, subtract my observations and arguments. In the meantime, it’s up to you to decide which is better for Husqvarna or Calm.

What is the difference between chainsaws

Tools from Stihl and Husqvarna are leaders in the production and marketing of gasoline-powered chain saws. It is difficult to say unequivocally which chainsaw is better. Calm or Husqvarna, because due to competition with each other, each manufacturer annually introduces new technologies, developments that facilitate and improve the operation of the tool.

Let’s compare chainsaws in some basic parameters that affect the performance of the units.

Chainsaw Husqvarna or STIHL?

Post by Vatar »Apr 16, 2016 8:48 am

What is the difference between chainsaws

Stihl and Husqvarna are undoubtedly the leaders in the production and sale of gasoline-powered chain saws. Due to serious competition, each of the companies annually develops many new technical solutions, introducing which makes it easier and more comfortable to use their tool. For example, Calm has such technical innovations as:

• STIHL M-Tronic system, which makes it easier to start the chainsaw, thanks to a fully electronic ignition system. The system independently distinguishes cold start from hot start. Also, M-Tronic accurately sets the ignition timing and adjusts the amount of fuel mixture at the time the chainsaw is started;
• HD2 filter. This filter is made of polyethylene, which has 70 percent finer pores than a conventional filter. It repels oil and is easy to clean, which adds comfort when servicing the chainsaw on which it is installed;
• compensator. This is a special device in the carburetor that allows you to work with a chainsaw even with a completely dirty air filter, and an important feature is that the saw practically does not lose power;
• catalyst, burns out unburned fuel, due to which the exhaust of the chainsaw contains less harmful impurities that adversely affect the human body.

Husqvarna Versus STIHL…might be surprised…you decide!!

If you look at the technical innovations of the Huskvarna company, then you can also highlight several interesting systems:

• Air Injection (air purification system) centrifugal air purification system, due to which the interval for cleaning the filter element is increased;
• The X-Torq® System reduces the amount of harmful emissions and, as the manufacturer notes, the tool equipped with this system consumes less fuel compared to chainsaws of the same engine size;
• AutoTune is a system for automatically tuning the optimal parameters necessary for stable engine operation. details about how the system works, the manufacturer does not indicate.

If we take two chainsaws of the Shtil and Husqvarna companies of the same volume, then they will be similar only in that they are equipped with an internal combustion engine, a tire and a saw chain. But everything, even the typical elements of these chainsaws, differ in size, shape and materials from which they are made. over, it is worth noting that thanks to the efforts of engineers, with the same cylinder volume, Stihl chainsaws have a higher maximum power, which will be noticeable when comparing specific models of chainsaws.

It can be noted that the Shtil and Husqvarna tools are perfectly designed and well adapted to the climatic conditions of the Russian Federation and, with proper use and maintenance, can serve for a long time. It is quite difficult to compare the tools of these companies, since their quality is very high.