Which is better for STIHL 180 or Husqvarna 236?
STIHL or Husqvarna chainsaws: which one is best for your garden?
A chainsaw will make life easier for the owner of a garden. This tool is for making firewood, and for removing unwanted brushwood, knots and trees. Preparing to buy, you are confronted with a large number of models, manufacturers. Let’s take a closer look at two popular brands: STIHL and Husqvarna. Let’s try to determine which STIHL or Husqvarna chainsaw is better.
The domestic series is designed for owners of garden or dacha plots, private landowners, farmers. The engine is powerful enough for home maintenance workers. The length of the guide bar is up to 40
55cm³. Power output of conventional and general-purpose saws is in the range of 1.4
2.6 kW. Trimming and thinning in wood, removing branches, felling medium-sized trees, construction work.
Husqvarna 135 9667618-04. the most inexpensive
Household class chainsaw, capable of small-scale operations: taking care of trees in the garden, cutting firewood, sawing small logs and boards.
The tool is equipped with a fuel-saving system that reduces emissions at the same time. Easy starting is ensured by a fuel priming pump and efficient air filter.
Recommendations: Top 10 Makita chain saws
Husqvarna 236 9673264-06. optimal for cottage construction
Lightweight, easy-to-use and convenient to operate. Complete with additional saw chain.
Powerful enough, well-assembled and tuned motor allows you to cut down small trees, sanitize woodlands, prepare half-finished wood for building a bathhouse, barn or other outbuildings for summer cottages. Inertia brake.
Husqvarna 240 9673260-01. easy starting
The chainsaw for domestic use. cutting firewood, tending trees in the garden, and occasional sawing operations when cutting logs for construction purposes. Vibration-damping system and rubber mounts on handles ensures comfortable operation.
Ergonomic body and inertia brake for increased safety. Engine features high torque and operating reliability.
Husqvarna 440e 9671558-45. versatile tool
Versatile chainsaw for many applications: felling trees, sawing for logs, taking care of private gardens and city parks. Used in the construction of wooden log cabins, outbuildings, road works. for clearing overgrown roadsides.
Chainsaw is equipped with reliable, economical, high-speed gasoline engine. Easy start system.
Husqvarna 455E Rancher AT II 9667679-15. the most powerful in the series
Chainsaw for year-round use. Equipped with a powerful two-stroke gasoline engine. Control and maintenance of operating parameters is provided by an electronic control unit.
The system stabilizes the mode depending on fuel mixture, temperature and humidity, air filter pollution. Safety inertia brake and extra face shield.
How chainsaws differ
STIHL and Husqvarna are without question the technological leaders in the manufacture and sale of chain saws with gasoline engines. Thanks to fierce competition, each company annually develops a number of new technical solutions that make the use of their tools easier and more comfortable. For example, STIHL has technical innovations such as:
- The STIHL M-Tronic chain saw makes it easy to start thanks to its fully electronic ignition system. System independently differentiates between cold and hot starts. The M-Tronic also precisely adjusts the ignition timing and regulates the amount of fuel mixture when the chainsaw is started;
If we look at technological innovations of Husqvarna, we can see some interesting systems:
Air Injection (air cleaning system) is a centrifugal air cleaning system that extends the cleaning interval of the filter element;
If you take two STIHL and Husqvarna chainsaws of the same size, they are similar only in that they have a combustion engine, bar and saw chain. But all, even the typical elements of these chainsaws differ in size, shape and materials of which they are made. It is worth noting that thanks to the efforts of engineers, STIHL chain saws have greater maximum power, with the same cylinder volume, which is evident when comparing specific chainsaw models.
Which chainsaw is better than STIHL or Husqvarna?
Let’s begin our comparison by expressing our deep respect for both manufacturers. These companies are undoubtedly leaders in the field of design, manufacture and sales of professional motor equipment for the forest and garden-parking industry. Naturally, the question: Which chainsaw is better than STIHL or Husqvarna. arises in almost every person planning to buy a saw and studying the reviews and opinions of experts. There are a lot of videos, articles and photos on the internet. As a rule, none of the brands has a clear advantage in forum discussions. We hope that our article will help clarify the issue. Below are reasoned descriptions, supported by facts and pictures, of the advantages and disadvantages of the following chainsaws: Husqvarna 236, STIHL 180 and Partner P340S. And Husqvarna and Partner are made by Husqvarna Group and the STIHL 180, respectively, by Andreas STIHL.
General chainsaw information.
- Manufacturer Husqvarna
- Where the factory is located China
- 35cc cylinder capacity. see
- Engine power 1.93 hp.с. / 1,45 kW
- 35 cm bar length, 14
- Weight 4,5 kg
- STIHL makes
- Where is the manufacturer’s factory China
- Cylinder capacity 31.8 cc. cm cylinder capacity
- Engine power 2 liters.с. / 1.5 kW
- Tire length 35cm, 14
- Weight 3.9 kg
- Husqvarna manufacturer
- Where is the manufacturer’s factory China
- Cylinder capacity 38,2 cc. cm
- Engine power 1.9 HP.с. / 1,42 kW
- Tire length 35 cm, 14
- Weight 4.7 kg
As you can see, these saws are almost identical in engine power and bar length. The STIHL MS 180 is the lightest of the bunch.
Detailed overview and comparison of the main components.
Despite the apparent external similarity of the objects of comparison, there are significant differences between them, which significantly affect the resource and performance. Without focusing on these differences, we can’t know which manufacturer to prefer: STIHL or Husqvarna.
The STIHL MS 180 and the Partner P 340 chain saws are equipped with classic two-stroke engines. Their drawback is the imperfect flushing system in the combustion chamber 20% of the fuel exits through the exhaust pipe (muffler) into the atmosphere with the combustion gases. That way we lose a fifth of the gasoline that goes down the drain, polluting the environment and even breathing in this rattling mixture of exhaust, gasoline and oil.
Husqvarna 236 chain saw features a state-of-the-art two-stroke engine with X-Torq technology, which provides near-100% fuel combustion. The result is up to 70% fewer toxic fumes than a conventional two-stroke motor. Also the complete combustion provides high torque over a wider rpm range. Husqvarna 236 harder to crush in wood.
For intensive work, we recommend the Husqvarna 236: You can cut faster and with less strain on the operator and considerable savings in fuel
Chainsaw air filtration system.
All chainsaws made by Husqvarna, and these models are no exception, have a two-stage air filtration system: first the air mass with sawdust and chips is sucked in by the propeller on the flywheel, and then the air flows to the upper cylinder through a spiral channel. Centrifugal force causes dust particles and filings to be ejected to the side and clean air to be sucked into the filter.
This keeps your Partner and Husqvarna chain saws running longer without maintenance on the air filter.
Also if you compare STIHL and Husqvarna chainsaws by the design of the air filter, you’ll see the following: the filter on the STIHL MS 180 is a molded plate of synthetic felt pressed by the cylinder head. The tightness of the pressure is directly related to the wear of the cylinder head latch. The filter, like on the Partner P 340 chain saw, is a plastic housing with felt filter inserts. The element sits firmly in its intended location no matter how worn the chainsaw’s engine cover is.
All chainsaws in the Husqvarna Group have a metal spring that effectively dampens vibration and keeps it from transferring to the operator’s hands and arms.
The STIHL MS 180 chain saw has rubber anti-vibration buffers. Fatigue comes quicker with it.
Easy start systems for cold engines.
To start a cold engine, it is necessary to pump fuel into the chainsaw system from the gas tank. On most saws, including the STIHL MS 180, this is done by pulling the starter rope 6-10 times. Partner and Husqvarna chain saws have a priming pump. This makes it much easier to start a cold engine.
Top 5 oils from well-known manufacturers
The chainsaw blade is subject to a lot of wear and tear when it is in use. To reduce the phenomenon forced lubrication of the sawing set is used. For easy movement of the chainsaw chain release oils, which are poured into the tank of the tool. What makes them so special is their high adhesive properties. These oils “stick” to the chain surface and are hardly likely to be thrown off by the centrifugal forces when the chain is running. For your information!
To lubricate the chain sprocket you just need a drop of oil on the sprocket bearing.
When analyzing manufacturers, experts take into account the reviews of gasoline tool operators and characteristics of technical fluids. The TOP 5 list includes products that provide good lubrication of working equipment:
- STIHL Forest Plus. Substance is made on a mineral basis in Germany. Pour into containers of 1.5 or 20 litres. The grease has high adhesion, protects the tool from wood resin, has a good preservative capacity. Among the disadvantages. high price and inability to work in sub-zero temperatures.
- Oregon 90844S. Manufactured in Great Britain from mineral-based materials. Can work at temperatures above freezing due to special additives.20°С. Reduced volatility and stable viscosity ensures economical consumption at all cutting speeds. The disadvantages are the high price, inconsiderate design of the canister.
- Gazpromneft Chain Oil. Universal multigrade oil made in Russia. Intended for chain, guide bar, chain sprockets of all types of chainsaws, equipped with both manual and automatic oiling systems. Has good adhesion ability, protects metal parts from moisture and corrosion. Good quality/price ratio. However, users are faced with leaky containers.
- Hammer Flex Bar Chain Oil. Produced and bottled in Germany from synthetic raw materials. Suitable for use at subzero temperatures. Friction-reducing additives reduce friction and wear on parts. The big disadvantage is the high price.
- Champion Bar Chain Oil. Country of production. Germany. It is based on man-made materials that decompose completely in the ground. A number of additives prevents wear and corrosion. The disadvantages include the excessively high price of the product.
Polycarbonate greenhouse at homeGrowing vegetables, flowers and herbs on your plot allows you to get an environmentally friendly harvest. Polycarbonate hothouses are made of.
When working with a chainsaw, one rule should be followed. use only lubricants from well-known manufacturers. They are guaranteed to provide reliable chain protection and increase the service life of the saw set.
Comparison by chain tensioning method
If we compare the method of tensioning the chain, then on all reviewed instances, it is carried out by using a screwdriver, which should be rotated by a special bolt. The only difference will be the location of the bolt. The Stiles have it on the front next to the guide bar and when you tighten it, the guide bar gets in the way of the screwdriver’s twist. On other chainsaws the tensioning bolt is located on the side and there is nothing to prevent it from turning. So the MS 170 and MS 180 models lose out in this comparison.
In six years, the machine factory founded by Andreas Stihl will celebrate its centennial. The first product of a small industrial enterprise, which later grew to become a large company, is a chainsaw with an electric motor. It weighed about 50 kg. From two employees at the time of foundation, the company staff grew to 20 and the range was enlarged by a chain product with a gasoline engine.
The second sample also weighed a little under half a pound. The company’s long history of constant product innovation, patents for the latest technology.
Today there are four categories of products available to customers:
- Household, aimed at the non-professional consumer, working on the land or near the house;
- semi-professional, used by farmers in large-scale farming for profit;
- Professional, for the forestry;
- special, four different categories.
Husqvarna or STIHL
Husqvarna or STIHL. which of these chainsaws is better??
Intriguing question, isn’t it?? I am sure that many connoisseurs of these brands of tools, they were asked, are asked and will be asked. Of course there are other worthy chainsaw manufacturers, but exactly Husqvarna and STIHL were made to adapt to our Russian conditions, these firms have earned trust and respect in the hands of tough Russian man for many years! And if it is so let’s consider these brands and this difficult question. Husqvarna or STIHL?
In fact, such burning question is, in my opinion, equal to the eternally tortured by all scientists unsolved problem. who was born, a chicken or an egg?? Indeed, this theorem has some strong supporters of the chicken and some strong opponents. supporters of the egg. And so in our case. fans of Husqvarna and fans of Stihl. Let’s solve this difficult question
To begin with it is necessary to put a concrete question. what exactly in these saws of different firms one or another supporter is interested in: appearance, power, comfort, reliability, service life, price. What is the purpose of the saw. professional or for everyday household needs.
Let’s look at professional Husska and Stihl saws and evaluate their appearance.
As the saying goes: “there are no comrades for taste and color”. It’s really hard to say objectively which saw is more aesthetically pleasing, but the designers of both companies did their best to make their product look good, so the choice is an individual one for everyone. Here is the body itself and its fasteners cause many questions. I mean the need to disassemble the tool. unscrew covers and the like. According to some it is better for STIHL. That, they say, in the “field conditions” to open the Stihl is more rapid and the risk of loss of attachment elements is minimal. Try to open up both models offered by me. I personally did not notice any tangible advantages of Husky and Stihl, for the life of me!
Speaking of “caps! If we consider “winter-summer” protection that prevents penetration of moisture, snow into the carburetor of the saw (and cooling in summer), in my opinion, the construction of the Husky is much better. I know that many will argue that the “device” Stihl, which includes a separate top cover with a marking jumper and “skirting” on the starter is more convenient and reliable, but in practice it is not shit more effective than Huskvarna protection.
We know all too well that when the saw “grabs” snow in the winter when felling, it starts “coughing, spitting” and throttling. I have worked with both models for a long time and I can safely say that STIHL is much more capricious in this respect than its rival! Yes, and the Husqvarna filter is made better than the Stihl filter.
To disassemble the saw in the woods at your place of work and to fix the problem quickly, you need a “star” wrench. A single master wrench is enough for the Husqvarna, which itself is more convenient to use than the Stihl’s crescent wrench.
Both companies have a wide range of professional and consumer models (of course, also farmer models). However, some of the company’s modifications are made directly in different countries. For example, Husqvarna represents chainsaws of specific models by other manufacturers in the following states:
- 137E and 142E. Husqvarna factory in the USA;
- 257, 254XP, 262XP, 262XPH. Husqvarna factories in Russia, in the well-known Khimki
- 268, 61, 55, 272XP, 281XP, 288XP. Husqvarna factory in Brazil.
The other chainsaw models are made directly in the country of Husqvarna, i.e. in Sweden. If you find another country of manufacture not listed above, it is a fake!
As for Stihl, judging by VIKI information it is the best selling chainsaw brand on the planet.
The geography of the legendary company’s plants is as follows: Germany, USA, Switzerland, Austria, Brazil and China. In the home country of the saw. Germany, there are 3 powerful factories that specialize in specific saw components and units. One plant makes crankshafts, polymer parts, tires, one makes electric saws, and one makes magnesium alloy parts. USA factory manufactures crankshafts, tires, spare parts, processes pistons and assembles units. The most popular brand of Stihl MS 180 which is purchased by majority of Russian population is produced and assembled at the factory in USA. Besides the classic product list, Brazil also produces pistons and cylinders. Saw chains are produced in Switzerland, blowers in Austria. And of course there is no China, which produces probably everything for a STIHL chainsaw.
So what are we looking at. which models? Let’s evaluate the saws from the professional line, the ones that, in my opinion, have the most popularity and application in our logging. I’m referring to the STIHL 361 and the Husqvarna 365 SP.
Of course, the STIHL MS 361 18 has more similar features to the Husqvarna 365 SP, but the price is already higher, so we will equalize the product.
As we can see, the Husqvarna has a larger displacement than the Stihl for the same power. Most likely, the same power is achieved by increasing the RPM of the Stihl engine, and from this we can conclude that the load in the engine is increased. Accordingly, the Stihl engine is subject to more wear and tear and reduced piston operation. However.
But there is unconfirmed information that Huska 365 is not assembled in Sweden, but in Turkey, and the quality of the piston and cylinder is highly questionable. On the contrary, STIHL is characterized by its quality craftsmanship, the individual components of which are assembled in the individual factories under the control of the company. So it’s all not a valid argument for the quality of the two companies.
Another no less debated and controversial issue in the “Stihl and Husk case” is the cutting headset: the bar and chains. The controversy is global in scope
So, what are the essential differences between Husqvarna and Stihl saw bars? That’s right. the presence of lubrication inlets for the sprocket: the Stihl doesn’t have them, the Husqvarna does. I want to point out right away that these remarks relate to the standard equipment of the sold saws, already by your decision, the bars can be replaced additionally. So is this a disadvantage or an advantage?
To Stihl it seems to be superfluous in the bar design, because the sprocket on the bar is fully lubricated. over, for longer service life it is suggested that the gearbox is filled with specialized oil to ensure proper penetration and lubrication of the saw elements. But does it really matter to us Russians who put not only motor oil but also refuse into the gearbox of our machines? Not only the sprocket, but the oil pump can’t take it either!
The HUSKWARNIVERS decided to play it safe and gave their new product additional lubrication holes to the sprocket that can be injected with grease from a specialized grease gun. This means that the sprocket is lubricated with oil from the gearbox in the lower holes of the bar (designed for chain lubrication) and with grease from the syringe in the upper holes of the bar. Ideal. yes, but as always there is a BUT!
Particularly during winter when the grease can freeze in the syringe, and the Russian lazy spirit doesn’t always play a role.
Another important clarification. STIHL is the only company in the world to manufacture its own cutting attachments. in this case the guide bar. Husqvarna, as far as I know, not only uses its own products in this area, which is desirable, but also uses the development of other firms. I, for example, have a negative attitude towards Husqvarna tires and always tried to use tires from other manufacturers, in particular “Oregon” tires, which justified itself on a Husqvarna chainsaw. Of course, the choice among professional tires is not uncommon and there are durable Husqvarna tires. from 3000-plus, but the as we see already “bite”. I used a good Husqvarna tire with oblique channels for chain lubrication and a removable sprocket. But again the price.
STIHL VS Husqvarna (Штиль MS 180 против Хускварна 236) ТЕСТ-ДРАЙВ
As for shock absorbers I can confidently call Stihl the leader. In a year of working with it, I never broke a single shock absorber, although the saw wobbled like hell!
I have to talk about oil for 2 stroke engines. Of course I should write a separate article about it, but I will touch upon some points.
It concerns the organoleptic properties of oils from both companies. Have you ever noticed how the Huskvarna oil “drags”?? It stinks like cats pissing on me. To hell with this stench, we are not going to smell it, the point is in the distinctive smell, which reeks of ammonia. If the presence of ammonia substances is indeed present in the product, it is “not good” for the tool, or rather for its engine! In contrast, Stihl oil has a distinctively pleasant fragrance and therefore inspires more trust in the product.
Well, my readers, I think I’ll call it a day. Of course, touched on not all, but it needs you, which will complement or on the contrary will reduce my observations and arguments. In the meantime it is up to you to decide which is better Husqvarna or STIHL.
General information about the manufacturers
STIHL was founded in Germany in 1926. and from the very first years of its existence has focused on the production of forestry equipment. To date the manufacturer has formed a wide range of gasoline chainsaws, as well as a separate series of various garden equipment. Products of this brand are represented in Russia together with components, consumables and branded accessories.
As for Husqvarna, its history accounts for about 400 years. The first mentions of it are connected with the arms factory, established in 1620. By order of the Swedish King. In the XX century the manufacturer has actively mastered the technology of designing products for everyday life, but subsequently the most attention is paid to engines and designs of gasoline-powered saws.
Which is better. “STIHL” or “Husqvarna? As can be seen, both companies have considerable experience in creating chain technology, but the advantage of the second manufacturer is a number of unique developments. Particularly exactly the chainsaws “Husqvarna” were the first to receive an anti-vibration system, automatic chain brake and advanced technologies of carburetor adjustment. Another thing is that today such solutions are used by almost all representatives of the segment.