Which Is Better Than A Chainsaw Or A Saw Compare
Performance Advantages of Electric Saws
In the domestic market, saws are presented in a smaller assortment, however, it is not difficult to choose a model that meets the stated requirements. Tools imported and domestically produced with a capacity of 1.8-2.5 kW are in stable demand.
The list of offers includes several models of saws of the popular INTERTOOL trademark, as well as branded electric drive models Solo, Oleo Mak, Stihl and MasterYard of different classes, costing from 1,800 to 20,000 rubles.
In the design of electric power units, users especially appreciate:
- Compactness and simple design;
- Fewer rubbing parts;
- Stability of operating modes;
- Trouble-free launch in difficult weather and climatic conditions.
The main disadvantage of household and professional-grade sawing equipment is in a small range, limited by the length of the electric cable.
In large-scale logging operations, the problem is solved by connecting tools to mobile power generators. At home, preference is given to powering the saws to the household power supply using special extension cords.
Advantages of branded chainsaw import
- Products of leading European brands are practically devoid of the disadvantages characteristic of cheap chainsaw equipment. Chainsaws of the brands Stihl, Husqvarna, Makita, Oleo Mak and a number of others have positively proven themselves in all respects.
- The use of wear-resistant materials and modern technologies for their processing made it possible to bring the production of branded chainsaws to the highest quality level.
Chainsaw or saw: the pros and cons of each option
The arrangement of the suburban area also presupposes a sufficient level of mechanization of labor-intensive work. When completing the minimum set of household tools, the question inevitably arises, which is better and more reliable: a chainsaw or a saw? A review of the pros and cons shows that both options deserve the attention they deserve.
Photo: saw and chainsaw
Saw application circle
The electric chain saw is quickly turned on by pressing a button, which saves working time by reducing the amount of prestarting.
- Due to their small size and reliable grip, the saws are used in the construction of wooden residential buildings, crowning of tall trees and other special work.
- In particular, the saw does not cause noise discomfort when working in closed spaces, does not create problems in the absence of exhaust ventilation.
- Longitudinal engine models are characterized by good balance, even cut, no kickback when the chain enters dense and sticky wood.
Tools with a higher power range can master the volume of work corresponding to the capabilities of semi-professional chainsaws.
The working set of household tools for many owners includes an electric and a chainsaw. The presence of two tools allows you to significantly reduce the cost and expand the list of sawing works of different levels of complexity.
The main disadvantages of chainsaws
In the list of shortcomings of chainsaw technology, the complexity of the design. The chainsaw, in addition to the power unit, includes ignition systems, an easy start and headset lubrication, a clutch mechanism with a drive sprocket.
Even with high quality, good interaction of all parts and assemblies, the number of failures of chainsaw equipment is an order of magnitude higher than that of models with an electric drive.
User reviews note the following disadvantages:
- Cold start problems at low ambient temperatures. In some cases, even the presence of an inertial starter and a booster pump does not save the situation;
- High price of service and repair, high-octane fuel, engine oils, spare parts and other consumables;
- For potential owners living at a great distance from service and repair centers, a deterrent from purchasing a chainsaw may be the need to independently eliminate complex failures and malfunctions.
These concerns are fully justified, since the quality and reliability of the main range of budget models are far from perfect, and the supplies of the most popular spare parts are made in insufficient volumes.
The basics of the popularity of the saw range
Many owners have been using saws for years, changing only saw attachments and electric brushes as they wear out.
- High efficiency of electric drives;
- Significantly lower maintenance costs and low-cost repairs;
- Self-service and routine maintenance that does not require special qualifications;
- Sufficiently large overhaul and service life;
- The possibility of using saw sets and chain oils designed to work with gasoline models;
- Minimum levels of vibration and background noise.
Replacing the most expensive part of the saw, the engine rotor at a price several times lower than the cost of replacing the crankshaft of a gasoline model.
Chainsaw or Saw? What’s better? Chainsaw or Saw? What’s better?
Every professional builder should take the process of choosing a saw responsibly. The same rule applies to amateur craftsmen. But people are faced with an important question. Which is better: a chainsaw or a saw? Let’s try to understand this issue in more detail.
Chainsaw: tool features
This chain saw is in demand among people. It works thanks to the presence of an internal combustion engine in the structure, which is connected to a chain. A simple mechanism of a classic look has an increased level of reliability.
The chainsaw is presented on the modern market in several main types:
- Household tools. Chainsaws of this type are suitable for occasional use. The gasoline tool is lightweight and small in size. Most often, a chainsaw is used to prepare a small amount of wood for kindling the stove. The basic capabilities of a gasoline saw are limited, since it is recommended to use it no more than two hours a day;
- Professional chainsaw. This tool is suitable for felling trees. A chainsaw of this type is quite powerful and multifunctional. You can use it up to 16 hours a day without interruption.
Such a chain tool has the following advantages:
- The chainsaw does not require connection to a power source;
- Such a chain saw is suitable for use in different conditions;
- Professional chainsaws are powerful enough, so they can compete with electric options;
- A gasoline chain saw can work for a long time without interruption;
- Gasoline tools have a high level of reliability and long service life.
Among the disadvantages of such saws are the following points:
- A gasoline tool during operation is harmful to human health, since it emits exhaust gases;
- Professional chainsaws make loud noises during operation;
- A gasoline chain tool creates vibrations that make the work process more difficult;
- Gasoline saws will have to be filled with gasoline, which is fraught with additional waste.
It is also worth remembering that starting a gasoline engine in subzero temperatures is quite problematic.
Features of saw operation
The modern saw combines the basic functions of a chainsaw with the advantages of electric tools. The chain is rotated by a gearbox that is connected to the motor. Modern saws are supplemented with automatic-type saw head lubrication. The electric saw motor is protected from overheating by a special relay, which will allow you to work in intensive mode.
A professional saw has the most important parameter. The power level of the electric motor. It is on him that you need to pay attention to when choosing a saw. The higher the power level, the more productive the tool itself will be.
The main advantages of the saw that directly affect the choice of people are as follows:
- The saw weighs a little, and its dimensions are very compact, which facilitates the process of performing work;
- The saw does not emit gases harmful to human health and nature into the air;
- The saw is very easy to use;
- The cost of the tool is affordable;
- During operation, the electric motor makes a minimum of noise, so the saw will not cause your discomfort;
- The saw is easy to start, which will allow you to avoid problems in the process of starting it;
- Modern saws, the choice of which is very wide, practically do not vibrate, so it will be much more convenient for you to use them.
But the saw is not without its weaknesses. The main points are the following:
- Saws need a power source for stable operation;
- Tools are afraid of precipitation and high levels of humidity;
- You need to take breaks every 15 minutes so that the saw does not fail;
- Saw service life is low.
The final choice of a saw depends on the characteristics of the tasks assigned to you and on the frequency of use of the tool. You must carefully read all the above features of chainsaws and saws so as not to make a mistake. Only in this case you will quickly cope with any work without experiencing any particular difficulties.!
How the saw works
After plugging into the network and pressing the “Start” button, the electric motor starts working, which creates rotary movements and transfers them to the canvas through a bevel gearbox or using a direct drive. The chain attached to the tire begins to move, at the same time oil is supplied to it by a pump from the tank.
Chainsaw: features, pros and cons
To fully appreciate the advantages and disadvantages of a tool, you need to familiarize yourself with its device, key characteristics and functions.
The principle of the chainsaw
The chainsaw is equipped with an internal combustion engine and is connected through a gear system to the saw chain. The engine and the chain are connected by the clutch key, which are metal pads tightened by springs. When the starter button is pressed, the engine starts to operate at a speed of up to 2700 rps. (idling). As the number of revolutions increases, the springs of the clutch key are stretched by centrifugal force and the pads are pressed against the inner surface of the clutch disc. It begins to rotate together with the gear wheel, to which the chain is attached, making 10 thousand or more revolutions per minute.
To ensure safety, there are 2 options for stopping the chain:
- The engine turns off. The stop takes 1–2 seconds.
- The inertia brake is applied. When the lever is depressed, the fixed steel ring grips the clutch disc, stopping the tool in 0.2 seconds.
The two-stroke engine does not require lubrication, it is enough to use a high-quality fuel mixture.
Disadvantages of chainsaws
The disadvantage of such devices is the complex starting system and time consuming maintenance. Before starting work, it is necessary to prepare a petrol-oil mixture in the proportion indicated by the manufacturer. The owner has to monitor the tension of the saw chain, the cleanliness of the filters and the breather on the tank lid (responsible for equalizing the pressure), monitor the oil level, which ensures the smooth operation of the headset. A large number of working units increases the likelihood of equipment breakdown.
The profile and pitch of the teeth of electric and gasoline saws is the same, only the number of cutters differs due to the difference in the length of the blade. Powerful models that run on petroleum products are equipped with tires up to 1 meter. However, such professional saws are used mainly in logging, ordinary household appliances are much more compact. Electrical devices are equipped with canvases no more than 0.5 m.
Power and performance
Saw power rarely exceeds 2.5 kW, and in gasoline models it reaches 5-6 kW. But even with equal power, the power tool will be inferior in performance, since it must be turned off for 20 minutes after 40 minutes of operation (on average) to avoid overheating of the motor. Gasoline does not require such stops, they are able to work continuously for 8 hours in a row (if you do not take into account the devices of the lower price segment).
The revs of gasoline models are on average a quarter higher than electric ones. Accordingly, their productivity and speed of work are higher.
Compare chainsaws and saws
There are many factors to consider when choosing a tool. This includes the required amount of work, and the conditions at the workplace, and possible restrictions on noise and environmental pollution.
Ease of service
The saw is very simple and therefore easier to maintain. The electric motor is practically maintenance-free. To move the bar or change the saw chain, on most electric saws, simply unscrew the large handy nut with a handle by hand. Almost all maintenance is reduced to timely lubrication of the tire and the main gearbox.
It is very easy to start using the saw: just plug into the socket. In the case of a chainsaw, you will need to prepare a fuel mixture, pour it into the gas tank, check for lubrication in the engine and gearbox. The petrol engine is started manually by pulling the starter cord firmly on the handle. It is not always possible to start the engine the first time. Sometimes you have to conjure up the additional fuel supply valve and the position of the “gas” button at the time of start.
The mixture of gasoline and engine oil itself also needs to be prepared and the saw’s fuel tank refilled in time. After mixing, the fuel mixture is poorly stored, so it has to be prepared every time immediately before work.
Even changing the tire on a chainsaw is more difficult than on an electric one, since it requires a special tool.
Due to the simplicity of the design, an electric chain saw can be, other things being equal, more reliable than a chainsaw. She does not have a complex internal combustion engine. The electric motor starts instantly and can be turned off at any second. It does not depend on the quality of the fuel and the availability of engine oil.
Modern chainsaws are also quite reliable. Long gone are the days when a lumberjack had to suffer for half an hour trying to launch the old “Friendship”. And now there is no need to carry a box of spare parts. The new chainsaw starts literally with one pull of the cord and serves faithfully for at least two to three years.
In addition, gasoline saws have historically been a tool for professionals. There are almost no cheap chainsaws, and the available ones are designed for difficult working conditions and heavy loads. Unfortunately, most saws are designed for rare use in “greenhouse” conditions and cannot boast of workmanship.
An electric chain saw is generally much cheaper. The simplicity of the design allows you to sell for a lower price saws comparable in power and performance with more expensive gasoline “brothers”.
Besides, electricity is relatively cheap. Using a saw, you can hardly worry about the price of its “fuel”.
Chainsaw is significantly more burdensome in terms of operating costs. For starters, gasoline chain saws themselves are significantly more expensive than electric trains. They are more complex. In addition, chainsaws are traditionally designed to be known to be reliable. And therefore expensive.
The cost of chainsaw consumables (gasoline and engine oil) is also thought provoking. Fuel is constantly getting more expensive, and the chainsaw is a very “gluttonous” consumer of fuel.
However, sometimes the need to work “in the field” allows you to put up with the high cost of using gasoline saws. In addition, the inherently longer service life of the chainsaw makes the investment in the tool more rational than buying a “disposable” electric chain saw.
Which saw is better: electric or gasoline?
- Design features
- Compare chainsaws and saws
- Scope of application
- Ease of service
- Which saw is best for giving?
Recently, electric chain saws are becoming more common. They are compact and low in price. A saw can cost ten times less than a gas saw. However, in specific conditions, both the one tool and the other have an advantage.
Most electric chain saws are designed for home use. They are compact, lightweight, but less powerful than chainsaws. If you need to cut several planks, trim openings in a wooden wall or cut some firewood, the saw performance is sufficient.
Gasoline saws were originally designed for bulky workpieces and have more power than electric ones.
The unit is easy to carry from place to place, changing the area of work. In order to start working in a new location, the saw will need to install a nearby outlet and spend time re-arranging the electrical cable. In addition, during work, you have to make sure that the wire itself does not accidentally fall under the saw teeth.
Any engine heats up during operation. When working with an electric saw, you have to take breaks of ten to fifteen minutes every half hour to cool the motor. But chainsaws are able to work for hours without a break. This also leads to the fact that the chainsaw is a more productive tool.
What is the fundamental difference between electric and gasoline saws
The classics of the genre are, of course, chainsaws. It was with gasoline technology that the history of the development of the motorized hand sawing tool with a chain began.
The main purpose of a gasoline chain saw is work in the field. The chainsaw can be taken with you to the country and outside the city, that is, where there is no such blessing of civilization as a stable household power grid 220 (V). The chainsaw is ready to cut and unleash trees until the fuel gurgles in the gas tank.
An electric chain saw is logical continuation of the gasoline tool. Modern technologies have made it possible to replace the internal combustion engine with a compact and lightweight, and most importantly reliable, electric motor.
Unlike chainsaws, saws are more suited to work in one place, close to a 220 (V) electricity source. A chain power tool is usually chosen by owners of private houses who intend to work only in their own area.
Which is better, a chainsaw or a saw.
What to choose, an electric or gasoline saw
Only a robot-terminator can cut an immense trunk of a poplar into logs in one go, and then immediately after that cut a cubic meter or two of a building board to the size. And the whole thing to do an ordinary hacksaw for wood. But jokes aside, sawing a large volume of wood does not tolerate manual labor. That is why in the bins of any subsidiary farm you can probably find such a tool as chain Saw.
This tool is just one of those with which a simple working guy can turn into that very cyborg, who can cut the trunks of immense poplars in one go with compact and neat woodpiles.
There are also cordless models, but due to the high cost, they did not receive wide distribution, and in general, the cordless chain tool is unlikely to ever become popular.
Despite the unified operating concept of chainsaws and saws, they are still designed to perform a different range of tasks. Of course, both types of chain saws have their undeniable advantages, as well as obvious or indirect disadvantages. This review will consider the features of gasoline and electric models, their pros and cons. This article will help you decide on the question of what to choose, an electric or gasoline saw.
- What is the fundamental difference between electric and gasoline saws
- The main disadvantages of gasoline and electric saws
- Benefits of gasoline and electric saws
The main disadvantages of gasoline and electric saws
As with any other technique, Bosch is not without its drawbacks with the chain saw.
The main disadvantages of chainsaws:
- Petrol chainsaws weigh an order of magnitude more electric models of similar power.
- Internal combustion engine is source of noticeable noise, saws run much quieter.
- Gas saws require regular service. The owner of gasoline equipment must constantly monitor the lubrication level, as well as clean the air filter and change the spark plug.
- Gasoline tool requires regular refueling liquid fuel.
This is where the obvious disadvantages of chainsaws end.
Regarding the weight of chainsaws, some craftsmen are of the opinion that the chainsaw should be heavier. If you make vertical cuts, then the chain will cut into the wood literally under the weight of the saw itself.
The main disadvantages of sawing:
- Power tool operation depends on the availability of a stable 220 (V) power supply. This means that the chain saw can only be used next to the outlet. You can’t work with a saw in the field.
- Any saw has a live cord, which considerably limits the free movement of the tool. The cord will get tangled under your feet, creating additional danger.
- Saw working life noticeably inferiort petrol tool.
- High level of repair complexity. The electric motor of the chainsaws is virtually maintenance-free, with the exception of the electric brush assembly. If the rotor shaft is deformed or the stator winding is short-circuited, it will be almost impossible to restore the motor using a handicraft method.
Notes on the operation of chain saws boil down to the fact that this type of sawing tool is intended for the most part only for home use. This technique is not physically designed for frequent and long work.
To understand which is better, a saw or a chainsaw, consider the benefits of these types of saws.
Benefits of gasoline and electric saws
In addition to significantly speeding up work and making work easier, chain sawing technology has many additional advantages.
Pros of chainsaws:
- Absolute autonomyb. The chainsaw can be safely used even in those areas that do not have electrification.
- High mobility. The absence of a live cord allows the chain saw to work from any position. With a chainsaw, you can freely move around the site without getting tangled in the wires.
- Reliability and durabilityb. The service life of the engine of an ordinary chainsaw is at least 5,000. 7,000 hours before the first overhaul. The same amount of internal combustion engines will be able to work out after a planned restoration.
- Good performance. The internal combustion engine provides a very, very good tractive power.
- Small vefrom. With equal power characteristics, the saws weigh much less than the gasoline models. After a lot of experience with a chainsaw, an electric tool will feel almost weightless.
- Low noise level. The electric motor is much quieter than an internal combustion engine.
- Solid power. Modern electric motors are capable of developing a very, very good tractive power. Electric models are very, very productive.
- Unpretentiousness to service. The chain saws do not need any maintenance. Power tool does not use lubricant, filter and spark plugs.
- High environmental friendliness. The absence of exhaust allows the use of chainsaws in the garden and vegetable garden, that is, where a good ecology is extremely important.
Let’s sum up and decide what to choose, an electric or gasoline saw.
Each type of chain saw has its own advantages as well as disadvantages. For work on the road, it is, of course, better to use a traditional chainsaw. If the master has to cut firewood from a building board only at home, then there is a reason to choose an electric saw.
But many experts are of the opinion that both types of chainsaws should be in the arsenal of a good craftsman. In this case, when working in the field, a chainsaw is used, and for working on your site it makes sense to use a light, quiet and environmentally friendly saw.
Working conditions and environmental friendliness
Comparing two tools. A chainsaw or a saw, many consumers pay attention to factors such as ease of use, as well as environmental friendliness.
Saws are quite easy to use: the tool is started by pressing one button. Quite lightweight and compact devices will become indispensable helpers for simple work: to cut something nearby at home, cut down knots, cut thin logs. But when working with a tree with a denser structure, the saw power may not be enough.
You should also take into account the fact that the power tool can work continuously for only 20 minutes, since its engine heats up very quickly, while chainsaws successfully work without interruption for several hours
When choosing a saw for work, you should be prepared for the fact that it will be possible to use it only under favorable weather conditions. Excessive moisture can damage the instrument. The saw is an indispensable tool for working indoors: the compact design in operation produces a minimum of vibration and little noise.
Chainsaws run on a fuel mixture. The engine of the tool is started by means of a starter cord
For many users who have not encountered chainsaws, the need to prepare a fuel mixture, monitor the quality and quantity of components, is a deterrent factor in choosing this type of product. Manipulation of starting and maintaining the instrument is not as difficult as it seems at first glance.
For work in closed rooms, a chainsaw is not the best option: the fumes and exhaust gases emitted by the tool during operation do not make it possible to spend a long time in an unventilated room
Chainsaws are less picky about weather conditions: light rain and even snow do not interfere with her work. But, at the same time, in severe frost, the chainsaw may not start at all, which cannot be said about the saw.
What is better than a chainsaw or a saw: a comparative review of units
The arrangement of a suburban area is impossible without the use of all kinds of tools. The question of acquiring a saw, necessary for sawing firewood and boards, as well as other woodwork, at some point necessarily arises before the owner of a country house. Which is better than a chainsaw or a saw? Both tools are noteworthy. The only question is which one to choose. Each of the devices has its own advantages and disadvantages.
The power supply is the main distinguishing feature
Since the saw is powered by electricity, this type of tool can only be used in places where it is possible to connect to the mains. It is convenient to work with such a tool at home, during construction. When working with a saw, difficulties can arise when it is necessary to carry out work not only in the immediate vicinity of the house, but also to process the entire area.
For smooth movement with the tool around the site for outdoor work, you will need to purchase an extension cord several tens of meters long
In addition, during active movement, for example, during pruning of fruit trees, it is necessary to ensure that the cord from the power tool does not get tangled under your feet and does not fall under the running saw chain.
The saw is more intended for construction work: it is convenient for it to cut wood lengthwise and cut thin boards. Saw cuts are even and smooth.
Due to the main feature of chainsaws. Mobility, they are an indispensable tool for logging. Easy-to-use tools can be used in virtually any position
The main trump card of the chainsaw is autonomy. The chainsaw will become a handy tool for farming in rural areas, where power surges are not uncommon. Owners who practice outings in order to organize active rest: a picnic, expedition, hunting or fishing can always take a handy tool with them in the trunk of their car.
The financial side of the issue
If we consider the purchase of an electric or chainsaw from a financial point of view, then saws are a more economical option. The cost of saws is an order of magnitude lower than their “gasoline” counterparts.
Electrical appliances are more profitable than gasoline ones due to the fact that they do not need to purchase consumables such as gasoline and engine oil. In addition, the saw models are equipped with fewer components and spare parts than gasoline units. Yes, the electricity needed to power the saw will contribute to the cost, but the cost of electricity is always less than the price of gasoline. Although economical models of modern chainsaws can reduce this price difference.
Regardless of what type of tool the owner chooses, the saw will become a real “magic wand”, facilitating the work of improving the site.